Musician Ashley MacIsaac ends lawsuit over Google AI summary falsely labelling him a sex offender

Ashley MacIsaac, seen here at the Celtic Colours International Festival in 2020, has filed a notice of discontinuance to end his civil lawsuit against Google over its AI summary falsely labelling him as a sex offender. (Celtic Colours)

Juno-award winning musician Ashley MacIsaac has ended his defamation suit against Google over its AI overview falsely labelling him as a sex offender.

Earlier this year, the 51-year-old fiddler had initiated a civil lawsuit with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice after he discovered the AI-generated summary at the top of Google’s search page — known as an AI overview — was asserting he had been convicted of a series of offences, including sexual assault, internet luring and attempting to assault a minor, and that he was on the national sex offender registry — all of which was untrue.

MacIsaac, who originally hails from Cape Breton, was seeking $1.5 million in damages from Google LLC.

“If a human spokesperson made these false allegations on Google’s behalf, a significant award of punitive damages would be warranted,” the lawsuit stated. “Google should not have lesser liability because the defamatory statements were published by software that Google created and controls.”

But on July 29, a notice of discontinuance was filed to end MacIsaac’s legal action. MacIsaac has not provided a reason for ending the lawsuit, but told the National Post he had no comment. CBC News has reached out for comment.

Google did not respond to CBC News’ request for comment on the discontinuance of the lawsuit.

Google Canada previously issued a statement in December saying its AI summaries shift frequently to provide the most “helpful” information, and that any mistakes are used to improve the system.

MacIsaac’s now-withdrawn claim lambasted Google for its “cavalier and indifferent response to its publication of utterly false statements,” stating that MacIsaac was owed a clear retraction.

Ashley MacIsaac performs during the East Coast Music Awards in Fredericton in 2022. The musician said the false claims caused him anxiety when performing. (Kelly Clark/The Canadian Press)

The company first began to introduce the AI overviews in 2024. They’ve since been the subject of controversy, sparking multiple lawsuits from companies and publishers who claim the feature has reduced traffic to their sites and criticisms from those who point out that AI is prone to hallucinating false information.

AI error led to cancelled concert

MacIsaac said in December that he found out about the misinformation — which he said came from online articles about a man in Atlantic Canada with the same last name — after a concert of his was cancelled by organizers who cited the AI summary.

MacIsaac later said the incident caused him to experience deep anxiety in subsequent performances, fearful that audiences may have seen the AI overview and his safety could be compromised.

In December, MacIsaac told CBC News that while he couldn’t afford to sue Google, many law firms had reached out to him offering to help out pro bono.

Read the full article at CBC.