False Allegations Hub

Wrongful Convictions · False Allegations · Memory & the Courts

USA

Men exonerated in Yogurt Shop Murders case one step closer to receiving settlement payment

Kate Norum and Tony Plohetski · 13 November 2026

The entrance to Austin City Hall, with “Austin City Hall” lettered across a canopy over glass doors, set in limestone and rust-coloured metal walls beneath glass high-rise towers.
Austin City Hall in December 2025. The City Council approved the $35 million settlement, the largest in the city’s history. Photo: Ajay Suresh / CC BY 4.0

The four men exonerated in the infamous 1991 Yogurt Shop Murders case are one step closer to getting a share of the $35 million settlement, according to a lawsuit filed Tuesday.

A judge in February declared the men – Robert Springsteen, Michael Scott, Forrest Welborn and Maurice Pierce – innocent in the 1991 murders at a North Austin “I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt” shop that killed Eliza Thomas, sisters Sarah and Jennifer Harbison and Amy Ayers. In September 2025, American serial killer Robert Brashers was identified as the perpetrator in the murders through DNA testing. He died by suicide in 1999.

KVUE first reported about the tentative settlement in early May. As part of the agreement, Scott and Springsteen will receive $9.8 million, the Pierce family will receive $10 million and Wellborn will get about $4.8 million.

The city of Austin shared the following statement on Friday regarding the settlement process:

“This lawsuit is part of the settlement process approved by the City Council earlier this year and is required to bring the legal process to conclusion. The City has been working closely with the plaintiffs on the settlement and hopes to complete final payment within the coming months.”

The decision by the Austin City Council will result in the highest ever settlement in city history. It came with an apology on the city’s behalf by Mayor Kirk Watson.

Prosecutors said that a botched police investigation wrongly targeted the men. Springsteen spent a decade on death row as a result, Scott spent a decade in prison and Pierce died years later as result of a confrontation with police that his family said was fueled by trauma. Wellborn – who was never officially indicted – told KVUE Senior Reporter Tony Plohetski in a February interview that his life was ruined by his association to the case.

Watson reiterated back on May 28 that he hopes the settlement to the accused brings relief and closure.

“There’s nothing that we or I can say to undo past wrongs. We can only mitigate our mistakes with action,” Watson said. “I’ve said previously that I hope the exonerations bring some relief and closure, and I hope that this brings proposed financial settlement agreement also brings some relief and closure.”

Originally published by KVUE on 13 November 2026