False Allegations Hub

Wrongful Convictions · False Allegations · Memory & the Courts

USA

Ohio agrees to $10.2 million in settlements with five men wrongfully imprisoned in Toledo murder case

Brian Dugger · 18 November 2026

The Lucas County Courthouse in Toledo, a pale stone Beaux-Arts building with a green-domed cupola, behind a statue on a plinth, an American flag and a stone sign reading ‘Lucas County Courthouse, 700 Adams Street’, framed by bare winter trees.
The Lucas County Courthouse in Toledo, Ohio, where Common Pleas judges declared the five men wrongfully imprisoned. Photo: Chris Rycroft / CC BY 2.0

TOLEDO, Ohio — The state of Ohio has agreed to pay a combined $10.2 million to five men who spent decades in prison after they were convicted in the 1992 killing of Vernon Huggins, according to settlement agreements attached to two Lucas County court judgments.

Lucas County Common Pleas Judges Stacy L. Cook and Ian B. English signed separate judgments Nov. 16 declaring all five men wrongfully imprisoned. Cook’s judgment covers Eric Misch, Louis “Louie” Costilla Jr. and Joseph Rickard. English’s judgment covers Ismael “Mel” Vasquez and Lorenzo Vasquez.

The settlements require approval from the Ohio attorney general, the Ohio Court of Claims and the Ohio Controlling Board. The attorney general’s approval forms and the proposed Court of Claims payment orders are unsigned in the documents reviewed by 11 Investigates.

11 Investigates reported extensively on the case.

The agreement covering Misch, Costilla and Rickard allocates about $1.8 million for each man’s time in prison and just over $1 million each for lost income. The Vasquez brothers’ agreement lists each $750,000 payment under provisions covering attorney fees, court costs and related expenses. It lists zero dollars for time in prison and lost income. The agreements give no reason for the difference.

In a statement to 11 Investigates, Lucas County Prosecuting Attorney Julia R. Bates said her office gave defense attorneys the evidence it received from law enforcement during the original proceedings.

“Following multiple evidentiary hearings, we became aware that additional documents had not been disclosed to our office, and thus, the defense,” Bates said. “Based on those concerns and other evidentiary challenges, we asked the court to dismiss the charges without prejudice.”

“We recognize the seriousness of the concerns raised in this case,” she said. “We promptly dealt with these issues and our responsibility to address them as the evidence came to light. We cannot speak to the considerations behind the civil settlements.”

How the convictions unraveled

Huggins was found beaten to death in Toledo’s Wilson Park on Aug. 4, 1992. Misch, Costilla and Rickard were convicted at trial. The Vasquez brothers entered Alford pleas, which allowed them to plead guilty while maintaining their innocence.

Lorenzo Vasquez told 11 Investigates in January 2025 that watching the other men get convicted factored into his decision to take a plea.

“I’m like, they’re getting convicted on bogus testimonies and no evidence. I mean, the odds of us getting convicted are pretty good,” he said. “My lawyers are saying, take 15 to life and you’ll be out in 10 years.”

Lorenzo was arrested as a teenager and remained in prison until 2015. Mel was the only one of the five still in prison when his charges were dismissed in January 2025.

The Wrongful Conviction Project began reviewing Misch’s case in 2011. After five public records requests over seven years, Misch’s attorney received more than 100 pages of previously undisclosed police records in 2018.

The records included Crime Stopper tips pointing to other possible suspects and accounts that Huggins was seen alive hours after prosecutors said he was killed. In 2022, DNA testing identified another man’s DNA on a bottle found near Huggins’ body.

Misch was 16 when he confessed to detectives. He later recanted and told 11 Investigates he was scared and felt pressured to agree with their account. Judge Gary Cook granted him a new trial in June 2024, and prosecutors dismissed his charges that November.

In December 2024, Judge Joseph McNamara ordered new trials for Rickard and Costilla and allowed the Vasquez brothers to withdraw their pleas. He dismissed all charges against the four men on Jan. 3, 2025. In court filings at the time, prosecutors cited Misch’s confession and said one detective had died, others could no longer recall key details, and witnesses could not be reached or were unwilling to cooperate.

All five men also sued the city of Toledo and former police officers in a separate federal civil rights case. Under the state agreements, if any of the men collects money from that lawsuit that qualifies under Ohio law, he would have to notify and reimburse the state. Repayment would be limited to the amount Ohio paid him and to what he actually collects after attorney fees and litigation costs.

Originally published by WTOL on 18 November 2026