When police rework a complainant’s statement
False Allegations Hub · 21 November 2026

A malicious prosecution claim settles
This case study by Peter O’Brien was first published by O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors on 20 November 2026.
Our client, we’ll call him Mr Reid*, walked into a police station and was arrested over serious allegations about events from many years ago. More than three and a half years later, a jury found him not guilty on every count.
His malicious prosecution claim against NSW Police has now settled.
How a malicious prosecution case happened
Our client had no criminal history. A complainant went to Sydney police officers and alleged serious offences against Mr Reid, and he denied the allegations from the start.
The officer in charge took a signed statement from the complainant. Two days later, he took a second one. We allege that the officer decided that the dates in the first statement did not fit other information he had, and worked through them with the complainant to produce a new version.
Both statements carried the same date. The first was never served on the prosecution or on Mr Reid’s lawyers. Police also obtained a provisional apprehended violence order. We also allege the page setting out the grounds was removed when it was served on him.
Mr Reid was arrested, held for several hours and released on bail. These bail conditions stayed in place until the verdict, more than three years later.
Claiming for false allegations by police
Mr Reid was charged with several serious offences, and the case went to a jury trial. His earlier legal team had obtained police records by subpoena, and among them was the first statement. It was raised in court during the trial.
The officer told the court the first statement should have been destroyed. Then the judge raised whether he should get independent legal advice before giving evidence, and described the evidence as deeply troubling. Later, the judge found that the officer’s conduct in preparing the second statement was improper.
After the verdict, we filed a civil claim in the District Court against the State of NSW, which is responsible for the conduct of its police officers. Mr Reid claimed malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, false imprisonment and assault, with aggravated and exemplary damages.
False imprisonment is about whether an arrest was lawful under the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002.
Our approach
Mr Reid had other lawyers for his criminal trial. We took on the civil claim after the verdict.
We worked from the trial record rather than from recollection. The court’s own findings about the two statements gave us a fixed account of what happened and when.
We built the claim around what a malicious prosecution needs: that police started the prosecution, that it ended in his favour, that there was no reasonable and probable cause, and that there was malice. We also pleaded misfeasance in public office, which looks at whether an officer misused their position.
We claimed the losses that a groundless prosecution causes. They included legal costs that had not been recovered, the cost of travelling and staying away from home to attend the trial, and the toll of more than three years on bail.
What is a malicious prosecution claim?
It is a civil claim that someone misused the criminal process against you. You must prove the prosecution ended in your favour, that it started without reasonable and probable cause, and that it was driven by malice, meaning a purpose other than properly using the criminal law. A not guilty verdict alone is not enough.
The outcome
A jury found Mr Reid not guilty on every count. The trial judge also granted a costs certificate under the Costs in Criminal Cases Act 1967 (NSW), after finding it would not have been reasonable to start the prosecution had police known all the relevant facts.
The civil claim then settled on terms our client accepted. As with all of our case studies, we do not publish settlement terms.
*We always change the names and other identifiable details in case studies to protect client privacy.
The detective in the Alan Jones trial
An extract from Clare Sibthorpe’s report in The Sydney Morning Herald, 18 November 2026.
A key detective in Alan Jones’ indecent assault and sexual touching trial has strenuously denied failing to make a “serious attempt” to investigate allegations by one of five complainants.
In February 2024, Detective Senior Constable Graham Kilgour was assigned to Strike Force Bonnefin, formed in response to a major investigation by The Sydney Morning Herald into accusations against Jones.
On Wednesday, Kilgour faced his third day of testifying at the Downing Centre Local Court, where Jones is on trial for 19 counts of indecent assault and two counts of sexual touching against five male complainants over 17 years to 2020. The 85-year-old denies the alleged acts occurred.
During cross-examination, Jones’ barrister Gabrielle Bashir, SC, suggested Kilgour’s statement-making regarding a man dubbed “J” was “not a serious attempt to investigate [J’s] allegations”.
“That’s completely incorrect,” Kilgour said.
Asked if “this was an endeavour to attempt to shore up [J’s] allegation against Mr Jones”, the detective replied: “No.”
Kilgour accepted that, while investigating Jones, he obtained statements from two complainants, including “J”, and had contact with a third accuser.
“J”, who was in August the first complainant to give evidence, was a teen athlete when he met Jones in the early 2000s.
The court heard Jones lavished gifts on “J” before allegedly indecently assaulting him nine times on four occasions and paying him hundreds of dollars weekly.
A different detective to Kilgour took the first statement from “J” in November 2024. In it, “J” said he met Jones at 14 or 15, got his driver’s licence on his 17th birthday, was bought a white Nissan Pulsar by Jones shortly after, and was subsequently indecently assaulted.
Kilgour had his initial phone call with “J” in December 2024, knowing Jones had publicly denied the allegations and would defend the charges.
During that call, “J” said that while he was in year 12, Jones began paying him hundreds of dollars weekly until about 2006-2007.
Before calling “J”, Kilgour ran registration checks suggesting the Nissan was not registered in “J’s” name until he was nearly 19, not 17 as claimed. Bashir put to Kilgour that these dates created “problems” for “J’s” account that he was under 18 during the first two alleged assaults. Kilgour said the point of the additional statement was to clarify unclear dates from the first statement.
Kilgour denied discussing the registration dates on the call.
Asked by Bashir why the weekly payments were omitted in the formal statement that followed the call, he said he needed the bank records, adding handwritten phone notes are not verbatim transcripts or formal statements.
While typing up the formal statement, Kilgour accepted it omitted details from the phone call and shifted timelines forward by one to two years – aligning with the car registration – reiterating that his task was to clarify when events occurred.
Bashir suggested the alterations “added to his original accounts in order to best accord with the independent records”.
Kilgour responded, “it added to his account”.
“There’s no way whether it was good or bad. It is what it was. He gave an account. He gave a statement. Records were obtained, and from his memory, from that additional statement, it either matched or it didn’t. And in this case, there were independent records that did.”
The report goes on to the bank records the detective emailed the complainant before taking his third statement. Read the full article at The Sydney Morning Herald.
Originally published by O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors on 20 November 2026