Did botched investigations send this Cape Cod architect to jail?
Denise Coffey · 12 November 2026

Robert Therrien has spent 25 years trying to clear his name.
The former Cape Cod architect was accused of setting a fire in 2001 that destroyed his business at Theatre Marketplace in Dennis. In 2004 he was convicted of four counts of arson and related insurance fraud. He served two years in prison, three years of probation, and had to pay more than $44,000 in restitution.
He has maintained his innocence since his arrest. Thursday, lawyers from the New England Innocence Project filed a motion for a new trial in the case.
The Project’s staff attorneys Stephanie Hartung and Laura Carey filed the motion in Barnstable Superior Court. They have new evidence that will exonerate Therrien, according to Hartung. The 87-page motion details how outdated fire science, faulty methodology, incorrect forensic accounting, and “ineffective assistance” of defense counsel led to a wrongful conviction.
Even the accelerant detection dog, Gala, didn’t escape blame.
Developments in fire science
According to the motion, the State Police Trooper investigating the fire determined that the fire started in the drop-down stairway to the attic over Therrien’s office because of the intense burn patterns he found. The dog’s indications and subsequent chemical analysis — both of which the motion flags as faulty — led investigators to suspect arson.
Scientists now know that fires burn most intensely where oxygen and ventilation are present, not necessarily where it was set, the motion argues. Plenty of oxygen would have been available at the attic doorway.
Secondly, the Trooper relied on a methodology known as “negative corpus” to eliminate possible causes of the fire. The reasoning was that eliminating potential accidental ignition sources constituted proof of intentional ignition. It was a widespread methodology used at the time, the motion said.
In 2011, the National Fire Protection Association mandated a scientific approach, requiring investigators to consider all potential origins and eliminate them only through rigorous testing against case data and fire science principles.
“It’s (negative corpus) so fundamentally unscientific, but it gets relied on,” Hartung said in an interview Nov. 11.
Originally published by Cape Cod Times on 12 November 2026