False Allegations Hub

Wrongful Convictions · False Allegations · Memory & the Courts

England

The Overturn podcast wins ‘true crime’ podcast of the year

Samantha Dulieu · 11 November 2026

About forty award winners holding their awards pose on a wood-panelled stage beneath a large screen reading “Independent Podcast Awards” in yellow-green letters, one woman in a blue sequinned dress reclining across the front.
Winners on stage at the 2026 Independent Podcast Awards (cropped). Photo: Independent Podcast Awards / Via the Independent Podcast Awards, as published by the Justice Gap

The Justice Gap’s The Overturn podcast has won the ‘True Crime’ category in this year’s Independent Podcast Awards. The awards were founded in 2023 to help uncover talent in the UK podcasting scene away from big media organisations, recognising work that ‘doesn’t always get recognition it deserves.’

Earlier this year The Overturn was shortlisted in the ‘Impact’ category of the British Podcast Awards – the only independent podcast in the category which featured podcasts by the BBC, SkyNews and FT. For over a decade, these awards have recognised excellence and originality in British podcasting, with this category highlighting podcasts that have attempted to move the dial on some of the most important issues facing society.

The Overturn launched in March this year and brings listeners into the real-life battles of people fighting on behalf of loved ones they believe have been victims of grave miscarriages of justice. The series goes shoulder-to-shoulder with those on the outside as they campaign for those on the inside. In the face of a dysfunctional criminal appeals system, they refuse to stop fighting to clear their loved ones’ names.

From families contesting the convictions of teenagers jailed for conspiracy to murder over group-chat messages, to a former police officer who alleges he’s been stitched up by colleagues, to relatives of four men claiming a corrupt undercover sting led to their terrorism convictions, The Overturn brings their fight for justice to the forefront with journalistic resolve and critical urgency. The series highlights potential police corruption to secure dodgy convictions, the discredited testimony of prison cell snitches, and murder convictions so dubious even the victim’s family believe the wrong man went down.

The Overturn is produced and hosted by Marnie Duke. Executive producers are Justice Gap editor Jon Robins and Calum McRae. The series has been supported by The Future Justice Project and the Justice Gap. All interviews by Marnie Duke are original. The cases in this series have all featured over the years on the Justice Gap (www.thejusticegap.com) and (in the case of episodes 3 and 7) in Jon’s book Guilty Until Proven Innocent (Biteback, 2018).

You can read Miranda Sawyer’s five star review in the Observer.

‘But as the true crime genre has grown, the question of whether the real criminal has been caught has become less of a concern. Some podcasts are there to simply lip-smack over the gore. The Overturn, a new independent documentary series, is not like this. In every episode, it examines a particular UK criminal case, but not for thrills. This show is about the miscarriage of justice… The biggest obstacle to justice is how the appeal system works…. I’m no conspiracy theorist, but listening to The Overturn can make you feel as though every institution is designed to preserve the power of the powerful at the expense of the little person.

— Miranda Sawyer

Marnie won silver Best New Producer at the 2025 Audio Production Awards and is the silver Rising Star at the British Podcast Awards 2025. Her work has been shortlisted for the International Women’s Podcast Awards and the Independent Podcast Awards.

All nine episodes of the podcast are available to listen to now. Subscribe via Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts, or listen online via The Justice Gap.

Originally published by The Justice Gap on 11 November 2026